These Salted Caramel Thumbprint Cookies are super easy to make with only 6 ingredients total! The tender gluten-free and Paleo shortbread cookies are filled with a no-cook vegan caramel and topped off with a dark chocolate drizzle and flaky sea salt. They’re perfect for the holidays!
Oh man, I am so full right now. Like, so so stuffed to the brim, full of delicious food. Tis the holiday season, right? I’m just a week ahead of Thanksgiving with the over-eating.
Monica from The Movement Menu came over to my apartment today to do some baking and photo-shooting together, and as soon as she arrived and saw the restaurant that’s in my building, she insisted we go there later for dinner. I’m already a frequent patron of theirs and happily obliged.
We were starving after a long day of baking pie and chocolate lava melting cakes (coming soon!!!!) and were one of the first people in the restaurant at 5 p.m., practically salivating for some food. Naturally, as starving food bloggers do at a delicious restaurant, we over-ordered a bunch of things to share.
And then, we over-ate. We started with life-changing brussels sprouts – I’m seriously obsessed with these brussels because they’re so flavorful and unlike any I’ve ever had. They’re Mexican-inspired, with tortilla strips and cojita cheese and tossed in a jalapeno vinaigrette. Seriously like veggie candy.
Followed by the Mornay Fries…topped with a garlic aioli and fried egg egg. Holy cow. Then came the pork spring rolls with cilantro sauce. And finally, the pork sugo, with polenta and fried sage and asiago. We were stuffed before the pork sugo even got to us, but it was so magical that we ate it all anyways, and rolled out of the restaurant, happily stuffed.
Now I’m sitting here stuffed to the brim, and I thought I didn’t want to talk about food because of how full I am, but now I’m just excited about all the deliciousness around! And you don’t wanna hear anymore about my meal – you wanna hear about the cookies staring at your face, right?!
These salted caramel thumbprint cookies couldn’t be much easier. For the shortbread cookies themselves, you only need three ingredients! Blanched almond flour, melted coconut oil, and maple syrup. Stir together, and voila – you have cookie dough. The dough is shaped and baked off, and then filled with the easiest ever vegan caramel.
If you’ve tried my Homemade Twix Bars, this caramel filling will seem familiar. It’s so easy to make, and there’s no cooking required. It’s a simple but delicious mixture of almond butter, coconut oil, and maple syrup. You can switch in peanut butter if you’d prefer, too. If you want to avoid any coconut flavor, I’d recommend using refined coconut oil.
After the cookies are filled with the vegan caramel, they’re drizzled with dark chocolate and topped with a sprinkle of flaky sea salt. After a brief stint in the fridge to firm up, they’re ready to be devoured!
These salted caramel thumbprint cookies are tender, flavorful, and melt in your mouth! When Monica tried one today, she noted that the cookie itself tastes just like traditional shortbread, usually full of gluten and sugar, and she’s right! They do, but way healthier.
They’re gluten-free, Paleo, vegan, and perfect to add to any and all holiday dessert tables, cookie platters, and holiday gifts. With the chocolate drizzle and touch of sea salt, they’re elegant as well as scrumptious. No one would ever guess how easy they are! Enjoy :)
Facebook | Instagram | Twitter | Pinterest | Snapchat
Remember to #bakerita if you try the recipe!
Salted Caramel Thumbprint Cookies (Gluten Free, Paleo + Vegan)
Ingredients
- 1¼ cup blanched almond flour
- ¼ cup coconut oil melted
- 2 tablespoons maple syrup
For the caramel
- 3 tablespoons creamy almond butter
- 2 tablespoons coconut oil melted
- 2 tablespoons pure maple syrup
- Pinch of salt to taste
For the drizzle
- 2 oz. dark chocolate chopped or chips
- Flaky sea salt
Instructions
- In a medium bowl, mix together the almond flour, melted coconut oil and maple syrup and shape into a ball. Cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes or up to 24 hours.
- Preheat the oven to 375ºF and line a baking sheet with parchment paper or a Silpat baking sheet.
- Form 15 balls with the dough, about 1 tablespoon each. Make an imprint in the center of each cookie with your thumb.
- Bake for 10-12 minutes for until light golden brown around the edges. Remove from the oven and use a small teaspoon to press down lightly on the thumb imprints again, to make sure theres room for the filling in case they puffed or spread in the oven at all. Transfer to a cooling rack to cool completely.
- In a small bowl, whisk together the almond butter, melted coconut oil, and maple syrup until smooth. Fill each thumbprint with the caramel.
- Place chocolate in a microwavable bowl and microwave for 30 seconds. Stir until smooth. Put the melted chocolate in a small zip bag, snip the corner, and drizzle over the cookies. Sprinkle with flaky sea salt, to taste.
- Place cookies in the refrigerator to set. Keep stored in the refrigerator.
Recipe Notes
Use refined coconut oil if you don't want any coconut flavor.
Recipe adapted from my Jam Thumbprint Cookies.
Megan @ Skinny Fitalicious says
Yum! I’m getting ready to do some cookie making this weekend. I seriously cannot wait. I love the comfort food this time of year!
Rachel says
Me too! Thanks so much, Megan.
Gayle @ Pumpkin 'N Spice says
Mmm that restaurant in your building sounds delicious! Now it’s making ME hungry! :) And these cookies look so good, Rachel! I love the salted caramel and drizzle of chocolate. My kind of thumb print cookie!
Rachel says
Haha thanks Gayle! Thanks so much :)
Cyndi - My Kitchen Craze says
Rachel your cookies are gorgeous! You make the best cookies! Love them and I need to try these asap! How fun that you have a restaurant in your building. I would eat there all the time. It probably would not be a good thing for me. So happy you’re loving your new apartment and getting used to everything in SD. Hugs friend!
Megan - The Emotional Baker says
That sounds like a great restaurant, but I’d much prefer to stay home and eat these cookies nonstop ;) I mean who can resist a thumbprint cookie – especially one with caramel filling!!
mira says
That restaurant sounds awesome! These cookies look mouthwatering! Love the combination, pinned :)
Amanda says
Oh my gosh I’d overeat at that restaurant too. Yum! These thumbprints look amazing. They’re a cookie I love at Christmas, but I’ve very rarely made them myself. These would be a hit at any get together!
Rachel says
They’re so easy, you’ve got to try them! Thanks so much Amanda.
Medha says
These cookies look awesome! Salted caramel and chocolate are always perfect together- these are the most gorgeous holiday cookies :)
Annie says
A healthier version of cookies with caramel AND dark chocolate?! I need these in my life now!
Karly says
These are the cure-all of cookies! Soft, sweet and delicious, and perfect for absolutely anyone. MUST try these!
Laura | Tutti Dolci says
I adore thumbprint cookies and these are gorgeous! Love that chocolate drizzle!
Kathryn says
These look delicious! I love how simple they are, thanks for sharing :)
Kathryn | nimblenote.blogspot.com
Diana says
Hi I tried making these last night but was having trouble with the dough – it was lacking moisture so the mixture would not bind and I could not form a ball, not to mention form them into smaller balls to then make a thumbprint in them. They kept crumbling! What am I doing wrong/what can be done to fix it? This looks like a delicious recipe. Am I supposed to be using a stand mixer? Thank you for your help!
Rachel says
Hi Diana – How odd! Sorry you’re having trouble. I’ve never used a stand mixer for this, so that shouldn’t be a problem. Was the almond flour you were using blanched and finely ground? Sometimes if it’s too mealy, it can make the cookies crumble and not come together into a smooth dough. I’ve made these cookies a bunch and haven’t had that issue – I’d try adding a bit extra maple syrup to help bring the dough together. Hope this helps!
Lindsay says
Are u able to substitute butter for the coconut oil?
Rachel says
I haven’t tried it but it should work!
Elle says
Tried to make these today…. what a disaster! Left my dough in the fridge overnight and of course, it was rock solid this morning. Left it out for a while to get it soft enough to form into balls. Dough spread a lot and the cookies are just a crumbled mess. Curious where I went wrong as I’m not new to baking but I havent used almond flour too much. I feel like the recipe should say that if you leave the dough too long it will get super hard, etc.
Rachel says
Hi Elle, sorry you had trouble with these. I’ve never had the dough get super hard after leaving it in the fridge…is it possible you added too much almond flour? That could havw caused the dough to be a lot thicker and the cookies to be crumbly.
april sherick says
Allergic to tree nuts peanuts and eggs. Can you use different flour (wheat)? What amounts?
Rachel says
Not sure if that would work, but I’d try subbing an equal amount of regular all purpose flour.
Saara says
Hi Rachel, just wanted to ask if the almond flour could be substituted for gluten free plain flour?
Rachel says
Hi Saara, I haven’t tested it that way so can’t make any guarantees, and every GF flour blend is different, but it should work!
Anya says
Hi! Just wanted to say that I made these for a gluten and dairy-free friend (minus the chocolate drizzle) and they were (in the words of Mary Berry) ABSOLUTELY SCRUMMY! Thank you so much for posting!
Rachel says
So glad that they were a hit! Thanks for sharing, Anya :)
Maria says
Can I use peanut butter instead of almond butter?
Rachel says
Definitely! Any nut butter will work.
Elizabeth Schneider says
These cookies turned out so so well! My family loved them too! I was a fan of the short ingredient list and the fact that they’re vegan as well. Thank you for all the wonderful recipes Rachel! Your photos always look mouth-watering so it’s hard to choose which recipes to make :)
Rachel says
So thrilled to hear you’re a fan of the cookies! Thanks for the feedback Elizabeth, hope you find many more recipes you love :)
Rhonda says
Can we sub almond meal with something else? Have an allergic kid at home. Thanks! Hi
Rachel says
Hi Rhonda, absolutely! You could try using oat flour to keep it nut-free for your family. For the caramel filling, sunflower seed butter works well to keep it nut-free.
Jessie says
Hi Rachel,
When I made these cookies, I had a lot of the caramel left over. Any suggestions on how to use it?! Also, I only got 12 small cookies. Thanks!
Rachel says
Hi Jessie, it makes a great ice cream topping, you can dip fruit into it, use it to sweeten coffee, drizzle over pancakes or waffles…yum! Yield can always vary based on how large you made them, and they are pretty small cookies.
Linda Piazza says
I started assembling ingredients about an hour ago, and cookies are out of the oven and decorated, including the 30-minute rest in the refrigerator. It was easy to assemble, and I hope my non-vegan guests will like them as much as I do.
Rachel says
So glad they were so easy and delicious for you, Linda!!
Fern says
Had the same problem that a couple other people had where it seemed like the dough was lacking a binder and just fell apart on me the whole time, I wonder if it can be an altitude thing? Besides that it is absolutely delicious.
Rachel says
Hi Fern! Honestly, it may be an altitude thing because I’ve never had that issue, but I’ve always lived at sea level so I don’t know much about baking at altitude, unfortunately!